Is the Pit Maneuver Legal for Police

The total number of people killed or injured as a result of the maneuver is unknown, as the country`s more than 18,000 police departments are not required by the federal government to keep track. During a prosecution, officials are charged with protecting the public while putting themselves in danger and making decisions under duress. Clearly defined policies and thorough training can significantly reduce the risk of injury to officers and civilians and the threat of prosecution. Without any of the PIT alternatives, the police department that chooses to chase a fleeing vehicle can chase the driver until he`s tired or out of gas, or try a more decisive tactic like PIT. Originally known as the “tactical battering ram” or “legal intervention,” this maneuver was developed and popularized more than a decade ago by BSR Inc., Summit Point, West Virginia, Advanced Driver Training Center, as Tactical Vehicle Interception (TVI), a formal training technique for law enforcement. The first major law enforcement agency to teach TVI as a technique for stopping fleeing vehicles was the Fairfax County Police Department (Virginia), which modified the program for police operations and named it the “Precision Immobilization Technique” or P.I.T. [2] When the car is slowed down with the brakes or stopped conventionally, Kinetic energy is converted into heat emanating from brake pads or rotors. When police hit a target car, its tires temporarily lose grip with the road and the rear is pushed apart in the direction in which it was pushed, causing the vehicle to yawn to the left or right. The kinetic energy still present in the vehicle system continues to force the car in the general direction it was taking before impact, but the wheels can now be lateral to the force vector. If there is not too much kinetic energy to purge, the car will usually slide and spin in the process. If there is an excess of kinetic energy due to the speed of the vehicle in front of the PIT, the car can overturn, soar into the air or suffer some other unwanted fate. The court ruled against Harris with unusual unanimity, as the late Associate Justice John Paul Stevens was the only dissenter. The court looked specifically at the danger to innocent people to innocent people created by a fleeing motorist to justify the use of potentially lethal force in a police pursuit.

As stated above, there is some controversy surrounding the PIT maneuver. This does not make sense in all situations due to the high risk of injury and death. In fact, in high-speed pursuits, it is not recommended to use PIT to subdue suspects due to the high probability of a catastrophic collision. Instead, it is recommended to use spike strips or other methods of apprehension. The target vehicle rotates in the opposite direction to that of the officer. The police car continues. Outside Atlanta, on Dec. 4, 2018, South Fulton police attempted to arrest a Hyundai Sonata that had been reported stolen. In September, a representative from Whitfield County, Georgia, used a PIT to stop his pursuit of a stolen car. The 21-year-old driver, Makayla Whitt, was ejected and thrown 50 feet away, and her left arm was severed under the elbow, according to police reports.

Whitt could not be reached for comment. When police investigated, they found a shoe near the scene of the crash that they suspected Daniels lost while fleeing, according to a local report. Last year, the Jacksonville Florida Sheriff`s Office conducted more than 200 police pursuits and ended with 61 of them with PITs, according to an annual report from the bureau. As Daniels drove past a cluster of townhouses, one of the officers performed a PIT maneuver during which he struck the right rear corner of the Hyundai with his Dodge Charger and turned it onto a sidewalk. The car smashed a utility pole and rolled down a steep embankment and came to a stop. Daniels ran into the townhouses and evaded police. The Los Angeles Police Department reports that he has used PIT maneuvers without death or serious injury since 2005. So, essentially, the conditions must be perfect for the PIT maneuver to be considered a viable option.

In addition, modern cars have reduced the efficiency of PIT. Miller: The Federal Law Enforcement Training Center trains federal law enforcement officers. Our department teaches federal officials from about 80 different agencies in criminal law and procedure. Part of the training focuses on the legal aspects of the use of force or when a police officer can use force on duty and the degree of force authorized. Now, Brad, the Supreme Court has just ruled on a use of force case. Can you tell us a little bit about the facts? When performed at slower speeds — typically 35 to 45 mph — the maneuver can be safe and effective in ending the pursuit, experts said. The typical PIT seen in North America can be used by police officers trained in the UK, usually in traffic police or armed response forces. Instead of being called a PIT, it is simply part of the “tactical contact”.

“Beyond a certain speed, there is nothing specific to a PIT maneuver,” Blum said. “It boils down to ramming two heavy vehicles into deadly projectiles.” Another category of anti-tracking devices is a high-strength cloth net or mat that wraps around the wheels of the target vehicle, immobilizing them. For a product, the mat must be placed on the road surface so that the target passes over the carpet. Another uses a mechanical arm mounted on a police vehicle to slide the net under the target`s chassis while the vehicles are in motion. Mosquito nets are very effective at safely stopping target vehicles, but they still require getting very close to the target, and the cost of the net, a disposable item, can be prohibitive for some agencies that are short on money. Lawrence: Good morning, everyone. I spent three years as a police officer at the University of Oklahoma, about a year as an immigration inspector at the old INS, and then eight years as a police officer at the U.S. Park Police in San Francisco, where I studied law. I spent five years as an active Air Force Judge Advocate before coming to FLETC to teach. PIT has been in the proverbial belt of law enforcement since the 1980s and has proven effective, but controversial.

The purpose of the PIT maneuver is to force a vehicle to stop, where officers can quickly surround the car to make an arrest. However, this is not always helpful, especially in high-speed pursuits, as there is a high risk of injury or even death. Thirty of the 67 organizations that use the PIT maneuver allow their officers to do so at any speed; 26 of the agencies have a speed limit, according to investigations by The Post. Eleven agencies did not indicate whether they had speed limits. At the time, there was no speed limit in North Carolina for PIT maneuvers used by officers like Motsinger who had undergone more extensive training.